Leave site Skip to content
You are here: Home » Misconduct cases relating to improper use of AI

Misconduct cases relating to improper use of AI

Date of request: 10 August 2026
Reference: 17909323

Request

I would like to know whether your force has started any internal disciplinary cases or made any referrals to the Independent Office for Police Conduct over unauthorised or improper use of Artificial Intelligence programs by your officers or staff in their police work. I would also like to know whether you have started any criminal investigations against officers or staff over these issues.
If there are any such investigations, I would like to know how many, the nature of the cases, their outcomes or their current status if they are not concluded.
I expect that any cases would be within the last two years. But please start the search from November 30, 2022, the date on which ChatGPT was made available to the public.

Response

Avon and Somerset Police holds information relevant to your request. However, we are unable to provide a response without exceeding the cost limit set out under Section 12(1) of the Freedom of Information Act 2000.

 

Our Professional Standards Department (PSD) does not hold a specific allegation category that explicitly captures matters relating to the use of artificial intelligence (AI). Following consultation with the team responsible for the categorisation of allegations, it has been established that any matters relating to AI would most likely be recorded under one or both of the following conduct allegation categories:

 

  • Category A – Delivery of Duties and Service
  • Category K – Discreditable Conduct

 

For the purposes of this request, complaint cases have been excluded as matters of this nature would be more likely to be recorded and dealt with as conduct allegations.

 

Between 30 November 2022 and 12 August 2026, PSD recorded 781 conduct allegations across 409 conduct cases within Categories A and K. However, these categories also contain a wide range of allegations unrelated to the use of artificial intelligence, and there is no reliable means of electronically identifying those that may be relevant to your request.

 

To determine whether any allegation relates to the unauthorised or improper use of AI, each allegation would require an individual manual review. Based on an estimated review time of approximately two minutes per allegation, reviewing all 781 allegations would take approximately 26 hours. This exceeds the appropriate limit prescribed by the Freedom of Information and Data Protection (Appropriate Limit and Fees) Regulations 2004.

 

Section 12 of the Act allows public authorities to refuse requests where the cost of compliance would exceed the appropriate limit. For police authorities, this limit is £450 or 18 staff hours. This represents the estimated cost of one person spending 2.5 working days determining whether the information is held and locating, retrieving and extracting that information.

 

Where Section 12 is engaged, it applies to the request as a whole, even where only part of the request would exceed the appropriate limit. In accordance with ICO guidance, public authorities are not required to provide information up to the cost limit and may refuse the entire request where the threshold is met.

 

However, under our duty to provide advice and assistance under Section 16 of the Act, you may wish to submit a refined request. Narrowing the date range of your request may reduce the number of conduct allegations requiring review and bring the work involved within the appropriate cost limit.

 

For context, the number of conduct allegations recorded within Categories A and K during the relevant period is shown below:

 

2026 (to 12 August 2026) – 126 allegations across 69 conduct cases

 

2025 – 179 allegations across 92 conduct cases

 

2024 – 219 allegations across 125 conduct cases

 

2023 – 239 allegations across 113 conduct cases

 

2022 (from 30 November 2022) – 18 allegations across 10 conduct cases

 

 

 

A request limited to a shorter period, such as a single calendar year, may be capable of being considered within the cost limit.


Was this page useful? Tell us about your experience.