Misconduct outcomes

04 October 2021

Allegations of gross misconduct against a former police officer have been proven following a hearing held at Police Headquarters.

Breaches of standards of honesty and integrity, and discreditable conduct, were proven against former officer PC Shannon Carnell at the hearing, which was led by an independent Legally Qualified Chair (LQC). PC Carnell, who was in her probationary period, had already resigned prior to his hearing taking place.

The allegations related to incidents in which PC Carnell drove alone on public roads without having passed her driving test. None of the allegations relate to her driving while on-duty.

Head of Professional Standards, Supt Jane Wigmore, said: “Former officer PC Carnell was given a fixed penalty notice, a £100 fine and three penalty points, after admitting an offence of driving otherwise than in accordance with her licence.

“Her actions were completely unacceptable and put other road users at risk. Thankfully her actions were initially reported by another police officer, who was concerned she had not passed her test.

“The public rightly expects officers and staff to act with honesty and integrity and follow the laws they have taken an oath to uphold. When standards of behaviour do not meet the high thresholds we expect, a thorough investigation will always be carried out by Professional Standards and whenever appropriate, misconduct proceedings will be instigated.

“In this case, our investigation resulted in a gross misconduct hearing held in public in front of a panel. This panel is always led by a legally qualified chair, who is independent from policing.”

PC Carnell misconduct outcome (PDF)

24 September 2021

A misconduct hearing was held at Police Headquarters for PC Kenneth Brogan.

The hearing, led by an Legally Qualified Chair who is independent of policing, found the officer had breached standards of professional behaviour. The panel imposed a sanction of a final written warning.

The full findings can be found attached to this page.

Supt Jane Wigmore, head of Professional Standards, said: “We and our communities rightly expect our officers and staff to uphold the highest levels of integrity. Officers’ involvement with members of the public they meet during the course of their duty must remain professional. In cases such as this, where behaviour falls far short of our standards, we will hold them to account.

“A panel led by an independent, legally qualified chair (LQC) imposed a final written warning sanction on finding that this officer breached standards of professional behaviour.”

PC Brogan (PDF)